NYC Library Funding and the “Budget Dance”
Written by FTP Steering Committee member, Dylan Flesch
Formed in 2024 in response to the Eric Adams’ administration’s budget cuts, NYC PLAN is a group of public library patrons and workers fighting for increased and stabilized library funding. Adams’ cuts were merely escalating a long-standing pattern known as the “budget dance” where mayors propose cuts in draft budgets, public outcry follows, and the City Council negotiates and restores some funding. Libraries are a key mayoral bargaining chip because they reliably generate public pressure, forcing the Council to use its smaller discretionary budget to fill the gap.
This ugly dance typically begins with the Preliminary Budget in January, when mayors propose the deepest library cuts. The Executive Budget follows in April, often mitigating (but not eliminating) the cuts. The Adopted Budget is then released in June, the result of negotiations between the mayor and the Council, and this budget sees the most restored funding. Throughout this six-month process, libraries must plan staffing and services based on whichever draft budget is the most current, creating instability that affects workers and patrons year-round.
The Fight for 0.5%
NYC PLAN’s core demand is simple: allocate at least 0.5% of New York City’s expense budget to libraries in every iteration of the budget in perpetuity.
Ahead of the 2025 mayoral primary, NYC PLAN brought this demand directly to candidates through mayoral forums, a public letter-writing campaign, and formal questionnaires asking them to commit to allocating at least 0.5% of the city’s expense budget to libraries in every budget released during their administration.
Then-candidate Zohran Mamdani repeatedly said yes. His campaign confirmed the commitment in writing, and he added both the 0.5% pledge and a promise to end the budget dance to his public platform. Pleased with this commitment, but clear-eyed about politicians, we expanded our campaign to the City Council, where 11 of 51 members publicly committed to fighting for 0.5%.
Mamdani’s Broken Promise
Soon after taking office, Mayor Mamdani broke his promise. Mamdani’s Preliminary Budget funded libraries at just 0.39% of the city’s expense budget, more than $143 million below his campaign commitment. The Executive Budget raised that to 0.42%, still over $96 million short. The final Adopted Budget reached 0.43%, leaving libraries more than $91 million below the promised investment.
This was precisely the budget dance Mamdani had pledged to end. Instead, he used the restoration of his own proposed cuts to present the final budget as a victory for libraries.
With a $125.8 billion expense budget, dedicating 0.5% to libraries would be a drop in the bucket for the city while making a substantial difference for the library systems, which will receive $538 million in total operating revenue from the city this year. Embarrassingly for him, Mamdani’s first budget allocates a smaller share of city spending to libraries than Eric Adams’ final budget: 43 cents of every $100 in city spending, compared with Adams’ 45 cents.
Winning Ground
NYC PLAN’s organizing successfully made 0.5% the conversational benchmark for library funding. The mayor, City Council, library unions, library leadership, media, and library patrons all debated funding in relation to our demand.
Unlike previous budget cycles, the funding restored in this year’s budget was also applied to the outyears (the three future fiscal years included in each released budget), rather than only the upcoming fiscal year. That’s meaningful progress, even if the total amount is far short of our goal and Mamdani’s commitment.
More to Do
The budget cycle begins again in January 2027, and NYC PLAN is already strategizing for the next round of this fight. This year, library CEOs requested increases well below the gap between the proposed budget and the campaign promise, instead of joining NYC PLAN in calling for 0.5%. The City Council largely delivered based on those limited requests. Next year, we want to find out what can happen if library executives fight alongside their patrons and workers for increased and stabilized funding.
If you’d like to join the fight, sign up for the NYC PLAN newsletter here, and email info@nycplan.org to get an invite to our next organizing meeting on September 13th.
FTP loves to hear from folks around the country about their experiences with their public library systems. Please reach out to us at forthepeoplelibraries@gmail.com if you would like to share a reflection in our newsletter.
🗓️ FTP Events
FTP’s Trustee Network connects elected and appointed library trustees across the country to talk about what’s happening in our library systems and how we can solve big problems together. Participants in prior cohorts are always welcome, as are currently serving leftist trustees. We meet the second Tuesday of each month, and our next meeting is on August 11 from 8-9pm ET (5-6pm PT); if you’re not already on the calendar invite or email list, please email us for more info on how to join!
Join the Friends & Foundations Network!
FTP’s Friends & Foundations Network supports folks who are interested in or already involved with their local Friends of the Library or Library Foundation group and are looking to connect with others working to defend and strengthen libraries. People with all levels of experience and from across the country are part of the Network, sharing resources, ideas, and providing support through a dedicated listserv and occasional online gatherings. Join us!
🏛️ Local Library of the Month!
This month’s local library is the Carnegie Library in Jackson, Michigan! Written by Rob

Helpful staff, cool old building, always thinking of innovative services to add. Place to get educated, entertained & helped.
We want to feature your local library in our newsletter! Thanks to Rob for writing in this month. Send us a photo and 100 words about what your library means to you and your community.
🏛️ Library Land Updates
Here’s a roundup of interesting reading and listening material that we think you’ll appreciate. Sometimes articles may be paywalled; your library card can often get you access to paywalled papers! In other news, sometimes it’s nice to use tools like Archive.today or the Wayback Machine.
These Maine librarians are helping patrons resist AI and Big Tech by Bridget Huber for Bangor Daily
Get Loud: Public Library and School Internet Access Is Under Threat by Kelly Jensen
Columbus Metropolitan Library now a union, with 86% support by Dean Narcisco for The Dispatch
Inside Dua Lipa’s Library of Banned Books by Ron Charles
Come for the Books, Stay for the Power Tools - The New York Times [gift link] by Sarah Diamond for The New York Times
Wichita Public Library may cut hours as city prepares to present budget by Sophia Gernander
How Gen Z Use (and Don’t Use) Public Libraries by Rachel Noorda, Ph.D, and Kathi Inman Berens, Ph.D
🎥The Power of Public Libraries: Toni Morrison Reflects on the New York Public Library’s Impact
Giannoulias Announces First-Ever Statewide Digital Library Resource Program
Budget shortfall could force Spokane Public Library to cut hours and staff by Mary Sherden
Denver Public Library ends laptop, hotspot lending program by Rhea Jha
NYC’s Trinket Libraries are the Cutest Thing Happening in Your Neighborhood Right Now by Jordana Drell Herman
The State of Library Cuts in 2026 So Far via Kelly Jensen
Librarians are hosting viral ‘Avoiding AI’ workshops for people who are fed up with Big Tech | TechCrunch by Amanda Silberling
Demoted and Doxed: What Happened When a Texas Librarian Fought to Keep LGBTQ Books on Her Shelves by Jake Gordon and Sam Donndelinger for Uncloseted Media
Libraries are on the ballot: It’s critical we vote yes by Ron Chew for Northwest Asian Weekly
Cleveland Public Library workers set Aug. 24 strike date if they can’t settle contract By Mary Frances McGowan, cleveland.com
National Book Ban Bill 4925 Proceeds to Senate Committee | Book Pulse | Library Journal by Magan Szwarek
📢 Take Action
Take Action to Fund Libraries in 2027 via Kelly Jensen
2026 Library Levy Proposal | The Seattle Public Library goes to vote on Aug 4, 2026.
🎟️ Upcoming Events of Interest
What’s happening at New York’s libraries this August via Gothamist
📚Aug 7, 8 | Bremerton, WA | Bremerton Zine Fest (BZF) in Quincy Square.
📚Aug 8 | Grand Rapids, MI | 12 PM–6 PM Grand Rapids Zine Fest at Fountain Street Church
📚Aug 8, 9 | Kingston, NY | CPW Photobook & Zine Fair at 25 Dederick Street
📚Aug 15 | Buffalo, NY | 11AM–4PM WNY Book Arts Zine Fest at 468 Washington Street
📚Aug 15 | Anaheim, CA | 11AM–4PM OC Zine Fest at Anaheim Central Library
📚Aug 22 | Chicago, IL | 2–9PM Zine Mercado at Logan Square
📚Aug 26 | Morrisville, PA | 12–5 PM Bucks County Zine Fest at Blank Space Community Center. Get Tickets here




